| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Alice Lloyd | - | - |
| Brescia | 2:08 | 2:34 |
| IU Columbus | - | - |
| Indiana University East | 1:58 | 2:24 |
| Indiana University Kokomo | 2:07 | 2:36 |
| Kentucky Christian | 2:15 | 3:15 |
| Midway | 2:02 | - |
| Oakland City | 2:03 | - |
| Ohio Christian University | 2:02 | - |
| Rio Grande | 1:59 | 2:27 |
| Shawnee State | 2:02 | 2:29 |
| St. Mary-of-the-Woods | 2:02 | 2:32 |
| West Virginia Institute of Tech | 2:08 | 2:35 |
| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Alice Lloyd | - | - |
| Brescia | 2:14 | 2:40 |
| IU Columbus | - | - |
| Indiana University East | 2:04 | 2:31 |
| Indiana University Kokomo | ||
| Kentucky Christian | 2:25 | |
| Midway | 2:08 | - |
| Oakland City | 2:05 | - |
| Ohio Christian University | 2:08 | - |
| Rio Grande | 2:05 | 2:32 |
| Shawnee State | 2:07 | 2:33 |
| St. Mary-of-the-Woods | 2:06 | 2:41 |
| West Virginia Institute of Tech | 2:13 | 2:45 |
* estimated by Runcruit using performance data of current and recent teams